Indian Harbor Insurance Co. v. Zucker

July 13, 2017
Case Type:
Business
Case Status:
Affirmed
Citation:
16-1695/1697/1698 (6th Circuit, Jun 20,2017) Published
Ruling:
'Insured vs. Insured' exclusion in D&O insurance policy bars claims by a liquidating trustee against directors and officers of the company because such claims are brought by, on behalf of, or in the right of the company.
Procedural context:
Appeal from the final decision of the United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan at Grand Rapids.
Facts:
Capitol Bancorp, a bank holding company, filed a chapter 11 petition in 2012. Prior to the bankruptcy and until plan confirmation, members of the Reid family served as the company's directors and officers. The company purchased a standard directors & officers insurance policy prior to the bankruptcy and extended that policy during the bankruptcy. A plan was eventually confirmed which limited the liability of the directors and officers for breach of fiduciary duty to pre-petition acts and limited recovery on such claims to the insurance policy. The claims themselves were assigned to a liquidating trust. The liquidating trust filed a lawsuit against the directors and officers and the insurance company filed a separate suit in federal court seeking a declaratory judgment that the policy's 'insured vs. insured' exclusion barred coverage.
Judge(s):
Sutton, Daughtrey, and Donald (dissenting)
Tag(s):
 
 
Summary by:      Daniel Waxman (Wyatt, Tarrant & Combs, LLP)

Volo, an exclusive ABI Member product, offers bankruptcy circuit case summaries within 24 hours. Case alerts can be filtered by circuit, case, or key word. Find out more at volo.abi.org.

Previous Article
Courts Split on Arbitration over Dischargeability of Student Loans
Courts Split on Arbitration over Dischargeability of Student Loans

Seattle judge disagrees with Florida judge on arbitration over bar study loans, while Second Circuit ponder...

Next Article
Delaware Bankruptcy Court Provides Guidance on Indenture Trustee’s Attorney Fees
Delaware Bankruptcy Court Provides Guidance on Indenture Trustee’s Attorney Fees

Nortel attorney advice: Voice objections and concerns throughout the case, and don’t be “Monday Morning Qua...

×

Try ABI free for 30 days. We'll save you time and money.

First Name
Last Name
!
Thank you!
Error - something went wrong!